Treats Under $5

Blue Buffalo Sizzlers Bacon-Style Dog Treats

$4.99

Hill's Science Diet Chicken Training Dog Treats

$4.99

Pure Buffalo Lung Steaks Dog Treats

From$3.71

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats Duck Wild Bits Dog Treats

$4.99

Temptations Hairball Control Cat Treats

$2.59

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken & Duck Cat Treats

$2.99

Temptations Creamy Dairy Flavor Cat Treats

From$2.59

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Chicken & Turkey Cat Treats

$2.99

Nature's Own USA Smoked Jumbo Rib for Dogs

$2.21

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats Salmon Wild Bits Dog Treats

$4.99

Higgins Sunburst Gourmet Treats Millet Bits

$1.99

Purina Dentalife Adult Tasty Chicken Flavor Cat Dental Treats

$1.99

Temptations Tantalizing Turkey Flavor Cat Treats

$2.59

Canine Caviar Buffalo Jerky Flat Dog Treats

From$1.99

Nature's Own USA Peanut Butter Flavored Cow Ears for Dogs

$2.39

Friskies Party Mix Natural Yums with Real Tuna Cat Treats

$1.79

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Trail Treats Chicken Wild Bits Dog Treats

$4.99

Temptations Tempting Tuna Flavor Cat Treats

$2.59

Nature's Own USA Odor-Free Premium Bully Sticks

From$4.19

Temptations Seafood Medley Flavor Cat Treats

$3.99

Nature's Own USA Smoke Flavored Cow Ears for Dogs

From$2.39

N-Bone Puppy Teething Treats Chicken Flavor Dog Treats

$4.99

Temptations Hearty Beef Flavor Cat Treats

From$2.59

Fruitables Wildly Natural Chicken Cat Treats

$4.89

Blue Buffalo Bursts Filled Seafood Cat Treats

$1.69

Greenies Smartbites Skin and Fur Salmon Cat Treats

$3.29

Fruitables Pumpkin & Blueberry Flavor Crunchy Dog Treats

$3.99

Bingo Free Range Buffalo Ears for Dogs

From$1.99

Fruitables Crunchy Pumpkin & Apple Dog Treats

$3.99

Blue Health Bars Baked With Pumpkin & Cinnamon Dog Treats

$4.99

Temptations Hairball Control Crunchy & Soft Chicken Flavor Cat Treats

$3.99

Fancy Feast Purely Natural Treats Variety Pack Cat Treats

$3.99

Loving Pets Purrfectly Natural Freeze Dried Chicken Cat Treats

$3.59

Butchers Block Butcher Bones Grand Royale Dog Bone

$4.19

Fruitables Crunchy Pumpkin & Banana Dog Treats

$3.99

Blue Buffalo Bursts Filled Chicken Cat Treats

$1.69

Higgins Sunburst Gourmet Treats Fruits & Veggies Small

From$2.99

Redbarn Peanut Butter Filled Hooves Dog Treats

$4.99

Redbarn Meaty Bones Dog Treat

$3.99

Fancy Feast Purely Natural Hand-Flaked Tuna Cat Treats

$3.99

Solid Gold Bone Broth Beef for Dogs

$4.99

Higgins Sunburst Gourmet Treats Leafy Greens & Herbs

$2.99

Temptations Classic Crunchy & Soft Tantalizing Turkey Flavor Cat Treats

$3.99

Fruitables Crunchy Pumpkin & Cranberry Dog Treats

$3.99

Cloud Star Buddy Biscuits Grain Free Tender Chicken Cat Treats

$3.49

Loving Pets Puffsters Chips Sweet Potato and Chicken Air Puffed Dog Treats

$4.79

Loving Pets Houndations Grain Free Chicken Training Dog Treats

$3.59

Redbarn Barn Bagels Filled Rawhide Dog Treat

$1.99